
How to Choose a Student Information System for a New York Charter School
November 11, 2026Before switching student information systems (SIS), agree on what will move, how your team will verify it, and who can approve the transition. Start with a trial import and a written acceptance checklist. Set the final move date after your team has reviewed the results and resolved the issues that would prevent staff from doing their jobs.
This checklist gives an IT director a way to organize that decision with enrollment, academic, operations, and reporting staff. Adapt the steps to your school's systems, records policies, and reporting process.
Table of contents
- Define the migration scope
- Test and reconcile the records
- Rehearse the switch
- Approve access and retention arrangements
- FAQ
- Sources
Define the migration scope
Ask each department to list the information it needs on the first day in the new system and the historical records it needs to retrieve later. Record the source, destination, owner, and verification method for each group.
| Record group | Questions for your migration plan |
|---|---|
| Student identities and enrollment | Which identifiers must stay consistent? How will you check enrollment dates and returning students? |
| Courses, grades, and transcripts | Which years will move? How will you verify course codes, credits, and grading scales? |
| Attendance | What detail will be available by date and class? How will you compare totals and corrections? |
| Contacts and permissions | How will staff verify relationships, contact preferences, and access restrictions? |
| Forms and teacher-created content | Which documents, attachments, comments, and templates can transfer? What needs a separate archive or manual setup? |
For each item, ask the incoming provider to document the supported format and any conversion work. Ask the outgoing provider about export scope, fees, lead time, and access after the contract ends. Include any separate archive in the plan and assign someone to test retrieval.
Test and reconcile the records
Agree on acceptance criteria before the trial import. Ask staff who use the records to help choose the checks and review the results.
Compare counts by record group and investigate every difference. Then inspect selected records field by field. Include examples that exercise the workflows you care about, such as a student who withdrew and returned, a corrected attendance entry, or a course with a nonstandard grading scale. Use authorized access and an approved transfer method for any real student records.
Keep an issue log with the affected records, expected result, observed result, owner, and next test date. After a correction, repeat the affected check and any dependent checks. Have the department owner sign off on the results for their area.
For New York schools, ask the reporting lead and any reporting partner to verify the relevant export from the trial system. Record the expected fields, codes, review process, and correction handoff. Confirm your school's current requirements against NYSED's SIRS guidance. NYSED Student Information Repository System guidance
Rehearse the switch
Write a sequence that names who takes the final export, who imports it, who checks the results, and who gives staff permission to begin entering new information.
Choose a cutoff for changes in the old system. Decide how you will capture changes made between that cutoff and the start of work in the new system. Ask staff to rehearse one enrollment update, one attendance correction, and one grading task.
Also write the recovery decision. Name the person authorized to delay the switch, the conditions that would trigger a delay, and how staff will receive instructions. If returning to the old system is part of the plan, test how information entered after the switch would be preserved and reconciled.
Before confirming a date, check the plan against your school's grading, enrollment, attendance, and reporting deadlines. Ask each department to confirm its staff coverage for the rehearsal and the final move.
Approve access and retention arrangements
Test access with representative staff roles. Check both the information each role needs and the records it should be restricted from viewing or changing. Ask the responsible school owner to approve those results.
Have your records lead confirm what must remain accessible, where it will be kept, and how long it must be retained. The U.S. Department of Education's data destruction guidance describes differing retention needs for student information and addresses disposal after data is no longer needed. Use your applicable requirements and school policies to set the plan for each record group. U.S. Department of Education guidance
Document the outgoing provider's return and destruction arrangements, including copies and backups, and request written confirmation when the agreed work is complete. Put those tasks on the transition checklist with owners and dates.
FAQ
How long should an SIS migration take?
Build the timeline from your confirmed export availability, conversion work, trial imports, staff review, training, and reporting deadlines. Ask both providers for their dependencies and lead times before choosing a date.
What if some historical records cannot be imported?
Document the gap and ask the records owner to approve a retrieval plan. Test that authorized staff can find and read the retained information before ending access to the outgoing system.
When should we approve the final move?
Use the acceptance criteria you agreed before testing. Have the responsible owners review the evidence, close the issues that block launch, and approve any remaining work with an owner and deadline.
Discuss your migration questions with EduSchool
Bring your record inventory and one migration question to a walkthrough so you can discuss your school's requirements. Book an EduSchool walkthrough

